EcoCafé Haiti’s first harvest of cherry coffee is complete. This represents a major milestone in the program, a milestone achieved by our Haitian employees without close supervision from their US advisors. The results of our harvest and processing are noted below.
The purpose of this report is to provide you with an update regarding how your donation and support have been put to use, and to make you aware of what to expect with the remainder of the program. The report comes to you soon after my recent visit of December 2009.
Objectives of the program
As you may recall, the objectives of the program are as follows:
To provide the community of Ranquitte with the ability to achieve economic self-sufficiency through the cultivation and export of Haitian coffee to the US and Europe. The program has been characterized as a “hand up, not a hand-out” program.
To provide food crop (corn, beans, manioc, etc.) for upwards of 40 families (approx. 250 people) whose land is deforested and unsuitable for cultivation, a total of approximately 60 acres, land owned largely by Haitians who are incapable of cultivating the land on their own (i.e., the infirmed, aged, widowed).
To restore a heavily deforested area of Ranquitte to a more natural state, thus eliminating the effects from deforestation, topsoil erosion, runoff, silting of the watershed, etc.
To provide fair wage employment for 25 agriculture workers providing income for the basic necessities of life for worker families, or approximately 150 people.
Recent Accomplishments
As reported earlier this year, our original objectives of restoring 60 acres of land to good health and planting those acres with food crop, Haitian Arabica coffee, and shade trees have been realized.Since my last trip in September, our 25 employees have devoted most of their time to purchasing, pulping, fermenting, and drying coffee from our 300 area coffee farmers, while also helping the coffee farmers with harvesting and cultivating their gardens. When time permitted, the team cleaned the terraces on our original 60 acres of reforested land.
The results of our harvest were mixed. Although we had hoped for a larger harvest, we purchased and processed 7,000 lbs. of cherry coffee yielding less than 1,000 lbs. of processed, green coffee.
Despite the shortfall in volume, our employees and coffee facility performed as planned.
Our equipment performed well. Our rainwater collection system supplied most of the water necessary for fermenting/washing the coffee. Our building held up well during the rainy season. Our composting and waste water treatment system worked according to plan. Our employees carefully monitored fermentation, drying cycles, moisture readings, and properly labeled each/every coffee lot. Our coffee purchase records were in neat and tidy order.
According to Dan Kuhn, President of the Hawaiian Coffee Growers Association and our coffee agronomist, the quality of the coffee is excellent.
The quality of our first batch was independently confirmed by an outside coffee testing laboratory in the US, a lab that rated our coffee “80 out of 100 points” on the Coffee Quality Institute scale (80 points or more is considered “excellent”). Second and subsequent batches will be tested again this month. After “tweaking” our recipe over the last few months, we expect subsequent testing to surpass the first batch rating.
Dan Kuhn helped our team to grade our coffee, separating the coffee by bean size after the parchment was hulled, and removing coffee defects. Several grading exercises were conducted with our grading team who performed remarkably well. The coffee will be sold as Fancy (large bean size with few defects), Premium 1 (medium bean size with few defects), Premium 2 (smaller bean size with a larger number of defects), and Peaberry (extremely rare, small round beans with high density) coffee.
On another note, we reorganized the Haitian management team, eliminating conflicting reporting relationships and emphasizing greater specificity of responsibilities for each manager. Hopefully, these changes will result in better decision making and improved accountability. George Derval, our Executive Director, will primarily assume responsibility for community relations, resource procurement, and higher level vision/leadership/direction. Reporting to George is Michel Deus, our field supervisor, and Frantz Pierre Roesner, our agronomist. Deus will continue to oversee the majority of our workers and execute specific field duties for cultivation of coffee and food crops, and reforestation. Frantz Pierre, our agronomist, will assume full responsibility for coffee processing, the processing facility, our plant nursery, and our new coffee demonstration garden. When needed, Frantz will provide technical support to Deus for field operations.
Lastly, we have established a process to roast our
green coffee on site in small batches and to sell the roasted coffee in one lb. packages to those short-term missionaries who frequent the Christian Flights International Ranquitte campus throughout the year. By doing so, we hope to generate modest income that will be used to pay for the employees and offset the cost of our coffee purchase from local farmers.
Lessons learned
As an adjunct professor of marketing, you would think that yours truly would have mastered the art of marketing, abiding by the fundamental principles of marketing known as the 4 Ps of marketing (price, promotion, product and placement). The good Lord has a way of humbling even the most experienced and supposedly learned…
Placement (distribution) and product (volume) problems: Dan Kuhn and I queried our Haitian team regarding the shortfall in volume, learning much about Haitian tradition and the do’s/don’ts of running a social enterprise in rural Haiti. Specifically, we learned that our requirement to harvest and process the cherry coffee on the same day proved difficult for the farmers. Since most farmers are situated a great distance from our facility, it proved difficult to transport the harvest the same day in which it was picked. Mind you, most farmers transport produce by foot, balancing the load on their heads…with only some being fortunate to do so by donkey. Although we remedied the transportation problem by staging pick up points using our director’s truck, the remedy was not put into place until the middle of the harvest season. In marketing terms, this is known as a “broken supply chain.”
Pricing problem: In addition to transportation, most farmers were accustomed to selling their coffee at the local market as “pile” coffee, coffee that is simply dried and hulled (i.e., not pulped, fermented or washed). Further, they sell their pile coffee as finished, green coffee for about US$.74/lb. Conversely, we purchase the farmers’ coffee as cherry coffee for US$.17/lb. After pulping/drying/hulling, green coffee is only 15% of the weight of cherry coffee; therefore, our price of US$.17/lb. for cherry coffee is equivalent to US$1.13/lb. for green coffee, a 50% premium over the local market price. Unfortunately, with most farmers lacking an education, it was not obvious that our cherry coffee prices provided them with a far better financial return while also obviating the need for the farmers to labor over and process their pile coffee.
To further complicate the pricing dilemma, coffee farmers sell their coffee locally by volume (also known as a mamit [a large coffee tin] for cherry coffee, or goblet [a tin cup] as green finished coffee), not by weight. On this trip, we solved this problem by holding a meeting with the farmers, educating them on selling by weight and not by volume, educating them on the economic benefit of selling coffee directly to EcoCaféHaiti and not doing so at the local market, breaking traditions whose roots extend to the beginning of time, so to speak.
Promotion problem: Lastly, although several Haitians now have cell phones, most of rural Haiti has no telecommunication infrastructure (i.e., no telephone, no radio/television, no printed media, no Internet, etc.). Accordingly, communication largely is accomplished by word-of-mouth. With our coffee farmers scattered over a 60 square mile area without regular communication/contact beyond their local cluster of farms/homes, many farmers were not made aware of EcoCafé Haiti’s “grand opening” in September. As such, many coffee fields remained unharvested or were sold in small lots at the local market. Although our employees made a vain attempt to promote our business by trekking to the outer regions of the community and using a bull horn to announce EcoCafé Haiti’s desire to purchase their coffee, by the time our “advertisement” was received, the coffee season was already well into its prime.
Despite these shortcomings, shortcomings that hopefully were corrected on this trip, the coffee farmers and employees remain excited by the prospect of next season’s harvest commencing in September, 2010.
In recognition of those farmers who supplied us with this year’s harvest, we held a 3 hour social gathering. In that meeting we provided awards to the top ten producing farmers, educated the farmers regarding coffee economics, and demonstrated the benefits of proper pruning and cultivation of their coffee plants. Dan Kuhn captivated the farmer audience with a PowerPoint presentation followed by hands-on instruction for pruning/cultivating. Although the allure of cookies and soda accounted for some of the audience attendance, the meeting was well received despite the added incentive. Out of the 10 largest producing coffee farms, about half were owned/managed by women with Madame Selma Derval capturing top honors as the largest producer, a cherry coffee harvest of over 500 lbs.
Next set of challenges
Now that we have a modest supply of parchment coffee (coffee that needs to be dry hulled before shipment to the US as green coffee), the process of exporting the coffee from Haiti to the US represents a challenge.
Based on our earlier experience of importing equipment/building materials into Haiti and the overly bureaucratic, perhaps corrupt, Haitian process, we must navigate a similar set of hurdles to get our coffee out of Haiti to market without delay and without overly burdensome fees and tariffs. Once the process is better understood, we have several coffee customers in the US who have expressed interest in our product. Our two key Haitian managers are chartered with navigating the exportation process, the results of which will be known in the next month or so.
To maximize profitability from our harvest, Dan Kuhn recommends we contract with a roaster in the US to roast and package our coffee as a finished consumer product, subsequently selling it directly to consumers at consumer prices. This is an alternative we had not planned to pursue until next harvest season. Although we had intended to sell our coffee indirectly as green coffee to roasters, the pricing advantage of a direct consumer sale makes this alternative ever more enticing. Conversely, the task of marketing and selling directly to consumers requires resources, time, and financial capital that go beyond what I am able to provide on my own. Fortunately, several supporters of the program have offered their volunteer services to help with this effort. A decision on direct consumer sales will be made in the next month or so.
With the harvest season over our employees will devote the next 6 months to the coffee farms, assisting the farmers with pruning their coffee plants and creating compost piles for plant nourishment. As simple as this may sound, we anticipate having to convince the farmers to prune their plants, foregoing one season of cherry coffee in favor of a fourfold increase in volume the following season.
Although our farmers appear to understand the importance of pruning, it remains to be seen whether or not they will accept our advice and support. As with pruning, farmers regularly burn all debris and don’t realize the benefit of composting such debris and using it to replenish the soil for better plant growth. Again, we wrestle with Haitian customs and tradition.
While most employees will be working in the coffee fields, the remainder of our team will work on increasing the coffee drying capacity of our facility, creating a coffee demonstration field adjacent to our facility, and supporting the local farmers with food cultivation (as has been done in the past). With the expectation of a significant increase in coffee volume next season, additional drying racks will be required. A demonstration coffee garden will serve as a model for the coffee farmers to follow, a model that demonstrates proper planting, feeding/watering, weeding, and pruning of the coffee plants. Lastly, as before, we will assist with planting and cultivating food crops that benefit the Christian Flights school children and our less fortunate farmers, a total of about 40 farmers, most of whom are unable to work their gardens on their own (the aged, infirmed or widowed).
Parting comments
Jude is our newest employee, our Goodwill Ambassador for EcoCafé Haiti. Jude is a special-needs adult in the community of Ranquitte. He is mentally challenged, orphaned, and incapable of caring for himself. Despite his handicap, Jude’s heart is as pure as gold, and most everyone in Ranquitte treats Jude with the dignity and respect he deserves. Jude’s father died many years ago. His mother passed away last year, and he relies upon hand outs as the only form of subsistence. Although he inherited his parents mud/stick home, his relatives from a neighboring community decided it was in their best interest to move into Jude’s home, taking advantage of his mental state and sequestering him to a small room in the back of his house. Thanks to a special donation from one of our donor corporations, Jude will be compensated uniquely with a meal/day provided by a local citizen, and will receive medical attention (as needed) and clothing. We are very grateful for the support of donors such as this who go out of their way to help those who truly are in need. To the left is a picture of Jude in his room and to the right is a picture of Jude with his newly acquired attire, only the second set of clothing he owns.
As with any entrepreneurial endeavor, risk plays a factor. Our program is no exception. As noted with this past harvest season, next season we face the risk of the farmers not supplying the facility with sufficient cherry coffee and/or the farmers not cultivating their crops as instructed. Although we think we have corrected the problems experienced in the recent past, the fact remains that next season may prove no different.
Although we will generate modest income from the sale of roasted coffee to short-term missionaries visiting the Christian Flights campus and from the sale of our exported coffee to the US, we still need to secure donations necessary for the remainder of the program. From this point onward, most of the donation funds will pay for our non-revenue producing activities (continued reparation of the land, food crops for those unable to tend their land, and assistance to coffee farmers for crop cultivation/harvest).
In conclusion, I want to thank each of you for your advice, prayers, and financial support. Without you, over 350 Haitians would have remained destitute, hungry, and dispirited. Because of your generosity, these wonderful people have a firm basis for a hope-filled future, a future in which they will be able to control their own economic destiny.
Should you find it in your heart to continue to support our program, such support in any form is most appreciated. To make a tax-deductible donation, please send a check with “EcoCafé Haiti” noted in the memo section of your check to: Susan Arnold, Treasurer, Christian Flights International, 580 Roy Arnold Drive, Danville, KY 40422.